Sandwiches in Horse Cave

Meat-filled sandwiches and cheese melts at 5 Broke Girls in Horse Cave, KY are available for pickup with sides such as fried okra.

Order online

Sandwiches to Try

Pork Tenderloin Sandwich

Pork tenderloin, lettuce, tomato, and tex sauce; choose grilled or fried.

Grilled Pork Tenderloin Sandwich$10.99Grilled pork tenderloin sandwich served with fries, lettuce, tomato, and Tex sauce.
Fried Pork Tenderloin Sandwich$10.99Fried pork tenderloin sandwich served with fries, lettuce, tomato, and Tex sauce.

“First of all, It was a hard decision choosing the Pork Tenderloin sandwich of one of those amazing burgers, but I’m glad I did. It’s so hard to find pork tenderloin sandwich at all and this one is amazing. Huge piece, tender, I had it fried and paired it with the home made Mac and cheese. My wife had the catfish. The piece was so big, it made the plate look small. She loved it. A must go to when you’re in this area code.”

Sweet & Spicy Chicken Sandwich

Chicken sandwich with bacon, Swiss, Sriracha; choose fried or grilled.

“Their sweet & spicy chicken sandwich is out of this world! I highly recommend this restaurant for everyone visiting the nearby Mammoth Cave National Park.”

“Rustic, with small town charm. My wife ordered the fried chicken sandwich (sweet and spicy?) and fries with all the fixins. I had a Heart burger and onion rings. Excellent food. Great service. It's not fast food, so come in prepared to relax and spend a little time.”

Breakfast Sandwich

Egg and your choice of meat fill this breakfast sandwich on Texas toast.

Patty Melt Sandwich

$11.99+

A beef patty melt includes mushrooms, onions, mayonnaise, and Swiss cheese.

“The best patty melt I have ever had! Definitely check this place out if in the area!”

Fish Sandwich

$9.99+

This fish sandwich comes with your choice of one listed side.

BLT Sandwich

$9.99+

Bacon, lettuce, and tomato fill this sandwich, with a side choice.

“Great food, fair prices and excellent portions! Our group had salad, BLT, catfish and the broke buster Burger. All were fantastic. If you're in the area hunting around the cave system, make sure to stop by. Very homey atmosphere!”

Chicken Fried Steak Sandwich

$10.99+

Chicken-fried steak with lettuce, tomato, and Tex sauce in a sandwich.

“The people. Everyone's food was fantastic. I had the catfish okra and smashed potatoes. Also in our group was a Cuban and a chicken fried steak sandwich. The onion rings were perfect. The Cuban was very flavorful.”

Cuban Sandwich

$12.99+

Pork tenderloin, ham, Swiss, spicy brown mustard and pickles, with a side.

“My husband and I stopped here for a quick bite. The best spicy chicken and Cuban sandwich we ever had...highly recommend.”

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$5.99+

Melted cheese between toasted bread comes with a selected side and drink.

“The food was perfectly seasoned and cooked. Everything was fresh, restaurant was clean, and everything at a great price! The onion rings are definitely homemade. Even the grilled cheese was grilled with garlic butter. We had burgers, salads, grilled cheeses, and grilled chicken. Definitely going to make it our usual spot!”

Ham & Cheese Melt Sandwich

$9.99+

Ham and melted cheese make a warm sandwich, served with one selected side.

“Food was hot and delicious the Onion Rings were HUGE and very delicious not greasy like a lot of places and the Drink mug was Gigantic, I did not need a refill. they have a small gameroom in the back of the restaurant. Plenty of seating and the servers were very nice and considerate. you have to stop in and check it out, a great little restaurant hidden at the end of the town. I had the BEST Ham and cheese melt I have ever tasted.”

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$9.99+

Pulled pork sandwich served with one side of your choice.

“Just great—I had the pulled pork sandwich and I wish I was eating it again right now. An authentic and fun spot for good food and nice people. Thank you broke girls!!!”

Roast Beef Manhattan

$13.99+

Roast beef and mashed potatoes sit on Texas toast under brown gravy.

“Had the roast beef Manhatten and my wife had the catfish and shrimp. The food was sooo good. She had fried okra and onion rings as a side and the onion rings were amazing. Service was great as well.”

Texas Tenderloin Sandwich

$10.99+

A tenderloin sandwich comes with one selected side.

“Service is great! The hamburger, tenderloin and fried chicken with mashed potatoes and gravy was all delicious. Size portions are shareable.”

Club Sandwich

$12.99+

Turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, and tomato fill this club sandwich.

POS Sandwich

$10.99+

Pulled pork, onion rings, and slaw fill this sandwich, with one side.

Something for Everyone at 5 Broke Girls

At 5 Broke Girls, sandwiches include chicken with bacon and sweet Sriracha sauce, plus roast beef on Texas toast with mashed potatoes and brown gravy. Chicken comes fried or grilled.

POS Sandwich pairs pulled pork with onion rings and slaw. Cuban Sandwich has ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and spicy brown mustard. Patty Melt Sandwich adds mushrooms, onions, mayonnaise, and Swiss cheese.

Visit us in Horse Cave, KY for dine-in, pickup, or delivery. Breakfast Sandwich comes with an egg and your choice of ham, bacon, or sausage, served with Texas toast; scrambled eggs are an option.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Patty Melt Sandwich — This patty melt has mushrooms, onions, mayonnaise, and Swiss cheese, with one side selected from the listed choices.
Pulled Pork Sandwich — This sandwich features pulled pork and includes one side selected from options such as fries, green beans, or mashed potatoes.
Fish Sandwich — This sandwich features fish and comes with one chosen side, such as fries, fried okra, green beans, or mashed potatoes.
Roast Beef Manhattan — Roast beef, mashed potatoes, and brown gravy are served on Texas toast, with two additional sides selected.
Cuban Sandwich — Pork tenderloin and ham are layered with Swiss cheese, spicy brown mustard, and pickles; the sandwich comes with a required choice of side.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Horse Cave area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.