Patty Melt Sandwich
$11.99+
Grilled beef patty with mushrooms, onions, mayonnaise, and Swiss cheese.
“Greatest Patty Melt. Found on our drive to Cave City. Would definitely go back!”
Explore the sandwiches menu at 5 Broke Girls in Horse Cave, KY, where pickup is available for a wide variety of satisfying options.
Order online5 Broke Girls in Horse Cave, KY offers a satisfying sandwiches lineup with something for every appetite, from classic comfort picks to bold, stacked creations.
Standouts include the Pork Tenderloin Sandwich, Sweet & Spicy Chicken Sandwich, Cuban Sandwich, Club Sandwich, Patty Melt Sandwich, and the hearty Big Tex, each served with your choice of side.
Visit 5 Broke Girls in Horse Cave, KY and enjoy your sandwiches your way — dine-in, pickup, or delivery makes it easy to get what you're craving, any day of the week.
Patty Melt Sandwich
$11.99+
Grilled beef patty with mushrooms, onions, mayonnaise, and Swiss cheese.
“Greatest Patty Melt. Found on our drive to Cave City. Would definitely go back!”
Fish Sandwich
$9.99+
Fish served as a sandwich with your choice of one side.
Big Tex
$15.99+
Texas toast stacks double meat, cheese, bacon, pickles, and BBQ sauce.
“Honestly I couldn't be happier with everything. I genuinely wish I was from the area so I could come more often but I figured I'd help spread the good word. My food was spectacular, I had the Big Tex or something like that and it's one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. Fried okra was perfect. Service was amazing. Definitely feels like a small town hidden gem and I hope more people visit!”
BLT Sandwich
$9.99+
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato layered in a classic sandwich with one side.
“Great food, fair prices and excellent portions! Our group had salad, BLT, catfish and the broke buster Burger. All were fantastic. If you're in the area hunting around the cave system, make sure to stop by. Very homey atmosphere!”
Chicken Fried Steak Sandwich
$10.99+
Chicken-fried steak comes with lettuce, tomato, Tex sauce, and one side.
“The people. Everyone's food was fantastic. I had the catfish okra and smashed potatoes. Also in our group was a Cuban and a chicken fried steak sandwich. The onion rings were perfect. The Cuban was very flavorful.”
Cuban Sandwich
$12.99+
Pork, ham, Swiss, mustard, and pickles fill this sandwich with one side.
“Outstanding catfish, Cuban sandwich top notch”
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$5.99+
Toasted bread and melted cheese come with one side and one selected drink.
“We had dinner from 5 Broke Girls delivered to our hotel both nights we were visiting, and it was excellent! The portions were generous and the food was delicious. I loved the variety of kids options and that there were multiple options of vegetables as a side for their meals.”
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
$10.99+
Pork tenderloin sandwich with lettuce, tomato, Tex sauce, and a side.
“First of all, It was a hard decision choosing the Pork Tenderloin sandwich of one of those amazing burgers, but I’m glad I did. It’s so hard to find pork tenderloin sandwich at all and this one is amazing. Huge piece, tender, I had it fried and paired it with the home made Mac and cheese. My wife had the catfish. The piece was so big, it made the plate look small. She loved it. A must go to when you’re in this area code.”
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$9.99+
Pulled pork sandwich served with one selected side.
“Just great—I had the pulled pork sandwich and I wish I was eating it again right now. An authentic and fun spot for good food and nice people. Thank you broke girls!!!”
Roast Beef Manhattan
$13.99+
Roast beef, mashed potatoes, and brown gravy on Texas toast.
“Wow! Best onions rings ever. Big Tex was 1 lbs of meat and stacked high. Great tasting. I suggest the Hart Burger. 1/2 lb of meat with alot of trimmings. Country fried steak with the green beans were out of this world. Daughter got Manhattan roast beef with Mac and cheese. Large portions and we left none. Highly recommended.”
Sweet & Spicy Chicken Sandwich
$11.99+
Chicken sandwich with bacon, Swiss, and sweet Sriracha sauce.
“Their sweet & spicy chicken sandwich is out of this world! I highly recommend this restaurant for everyone visiting the nearby Mammoth Cave National Park.”
Club Sandwich
$12.99+
Turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, and tomato fill this sandwich.
Ham & Cheese Melt Sandwich
$9.99+
A hot sandwich with ham and melted cheese, served with one side.
POS Sandwich
$10.99+
Pulled pork sandwich with onion rings, slaw, and one selected side.
Texas Tenderloin Sandwich
$10.99+
Breaded pork tenderloin on a bun comes with one required side.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.