Skip to main content
Chicken Fried Chicken

American Food in Horse Cave

Enjoy American food at 5 Broke Girls in Horse Cave, KY, where a satisfying menu is available for pickup any day of the week.

Order online

Something for Everyone at 5 Broke Girls

5 Broke Girls in Horse Cave, KY serves up a hearty American food menu with something for everyone, from snacks and sides to full lunch and dinner plates.

Crowd-pleasing options include Chicken Fried Chicken, Southwest Chicken, Pork Chops, Broke Girls Fries, Wings, and the indulgent 5 Broke Girls Spelunker dessert.

Come visit 5 Broke Girls in Horse Cave, KY and enjoy your American food favorites your way — dine-in, pickup, or delivery all make it easy to dig in.

American Food to Try

Catfish

$11.99+

Catfish served in a selected size with two chosen sides.

“Sorry I’m too busy eating food to take pictures of the food but I snapped a couple before the meal. But anyhow; one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. And my party of 10 had a variety of dishes and everyone loved their food. Especially the catfish which frankly was cooked perfectly. I’ll be back super soon. And it’s way out of my way. But well worth the drive. Good stuff. Great find.”

Corn

$2.99

Corn is served as a simple, naturally sweet vegetable side.

“We had dinner from 5 Broke Girls delivered to our hotel both nights we were visiting, and it was excellent! The portions were generous and the food was delicious. I loved the variety of kids options and that there were multiple options of vegetables as a side for their meals.”

Corn Dog

$4.99+

A fried, cornmeal-battered hot dog comes with a side and drink choice.

“We loved our meal at 5 Broke Girls. We were staying nearby at the Wigwam Village and we were recommended this. We absolutely loved the food here. It’s great comfort food, our server was very sweet, and explained a couple of things we didn’t understand on the menu. They had a lively atmosphere, with live music when we went in for dinner. Would definitely visit again!”

Fried Pickles

$8.99

Hand-battered and deep-fried pickles are served as a savory snack.

“I was so excited to come here while visiting Mammoth Cave. After reading about it in the Kentucky Living Magazine, I had high expectations for their burgers. ...and they didn't disappoint!!! O - M - G. Amazing! And the onion rings and fried pickles are the best I've ever had (and we've tried our fair share of them all around the region). Good stuff!!!”

Mac & Cheese

$2.99

Creamy macaroni and cheese served as a comforting side dish.

“i’m from philadelphia on a road trip, a friend recommended this spot saying they have the best burgers in kentucky- they absolutely do. i got the fried pickles, broke buster burger, and mac & cheese. awesome. great food & super generous portions. super sweet staff as well. definitely a must try”

Pinto Beans

$2.99

Pinto beans are served as a classic savory side.

“After our cave tour, we had lunch at 5 Broke Girls. The food was very tasty and loved the iced tea . We did half sweet, half regular, and they served it in a small pitcher. We each got our own pitcher. Hubby ordered the Hamburger Steak. For his sides, he ordered fried okra, pinto beans, and cornbread. Cornbread was moist and slightly sweet, and the okra was fried just right. I ordered the Hart burger with everything on it with a side of fries. Burger was huge, and the fires were delicious.”

Pork Chops

$11.99+

Two pork chops, prepared fried or grilled, come with two selected sides.

“The owner was the cook. And let me tell yall! BEST PATTY MELT u will ever have in your life 50/10. 25 star restaurant … my fried okra was 🫠🫠🫠 the sweet tea was good and came in cute little pitcher ….. the pork chop was delicious 🤤 everything was amazing thank you !!!! Now yall see grab a bite to eat cause they worth the drive”

Rojo Potatoes

$8.99

Hand-battered, deep-fried sliced potatoes with ranch or cheese sauce.

“What a delightful lunch stop after a morning at KY Down Under. Friendly, prompt service and hot, cooked to order food. Really appreciate that everything was HAND BREADED— not pre-breaded and frozen from a food supply company. Extra points for the kid friendly atmosphere and game room in the back with arcade games that still only cost $.25!”

Sampler

$12.99

Sampler with four selected appetizers, excluding Broke Girls Fries.

“Omg this place has great food! We love going to local places when we travel and we spent the 4th in Cave City and Horse Cave. We put 5 Broke Girls high on the to-do list because of their reputation and they did not disappoint!! Get the onion rings, for sure. They were handmade and delicious.... all of it was great. Just an awesome place to eat some real good southern home cooking.”

Southwest Chicken

$13.55+

Grilled chicken smothered in mushrooms and onions with American cheese.

“This place was recommended by a co-worker of my husband’s when he heard we were going to Mammoth Cave. We prefer local diners when we travel. This place had wonderful food! Husband got the chicken fried steak and it tasted like it was hand breaded, so delicious! I got the southwest chicken and it was juicy and plentiful. Generous portions and attentive waitstaff. We will stop again if we find ourselves back in the area!”

Tots

$2.99

Crispy potato tots served as a classic savory side.

“My husband & I throughly enjoyed our lunches & the decor was interesting & our waitress was great (inspite of being run ragid). It is for sale, so if you are visiting Horse City, you may want to call ahead to make sure they are still there. It was crazy busy, but we didn't have to wait to be seated & we enjoyed the overall experience as well as our meals. Burger & onion rings Porch chips green bean tater tots

Twisted Taters

$8.99

Cajun-seasoned twisted steak fries arrive with cheese sauce for dipping.

“So glad we stopped here on our road trip back to Texas. Home style cooking . Had the lunch special chicken and dumplings, hubby had their huge hamburger. Tea comes in your own personal pitcher- just add the straw. Food was definitely home made. For desert had one of their many desert choices- chose the caramel apple dump cake since it's fall ya'll. Met the owner who is from Texas- and menu, friendliness, and atmosphere speak to that. Wish we lived closer- it would be a weekly visit. Highly recommend!”

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular American food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Catfish — Choose regular or large catfish, then select two required sides from the available side choices.
  • Southwest Chicken — This grilled chicken entrée includes your choice of two sides, with a side salad available as an optional addition.
  • Chicken & Waffles — This dish pairs chicken with waffles, and you choose either three or five chicken pieces.
  • Rojo Potatoes — Sliced potatoes are battered, deep-fried, and served with your required choice of ranch or cheese sauce.
  • Chicken Fried Chicken — This entrée is fried chicken served with two required sides, with a side salad available as an optional addition.
Do you offer delivery and takeout?
Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for american food throughout the Horse Cave area. Order your american food online for convenient pickup or delivery.